J

I’m 23 and in a class about cultural diversity as part of a teaching credential program, and we are discussing high schools (in CA, USA) that have created Ethnic Studies classes and departments. A middle-aged, white, male classmate in my discussion group says something about how racism doesn’t exist anymore – his evidence is that when he was younger, he used to play pick-up basketball games with some black men at his local YMCA.

I’m pretty well-versed in current Ethnic Studies theory, having taken several courses in college on it and reading on my own because I find the subject interesting (I nearly began this paragraph with an apology for tooting my own horn – as though I, a teacher no less, should be ashamed of my own education!). So I responded to his comment by explaining the difference between overt racism and institutionalized racism, and then giving a few examples of the latter, which clearly does still exist today. I think I did a pretty decent job of refuting his point with fair evidence. His response was to pat me on the head and say, “I hope you aren’t angry. I just wanted to see how well you would defend your argument. Good job!”

What I should have said to him:
1) What in the HELL makes you think it is okay to touch me at all? I am younger than you and female, so you think you should treat me like I’m your DAUGHTER? I wonder if this is how you end all academic discussions – do you pat the heads of the other middle-aged male classmates too? How do you think they would respond if you did?

2) Am I angry? Now that you’ve patronized me, obviously. But before, when you just made an ignorant, ill-founded argument about a subject that I know more about than you? Of course not. If those sorts of statements made me angry, I would not be able to handle teaching high school students.

3)Right. So now that I’ve effectively shown the flaws in your argument, you’re going to claim that it was all really some kind of test for me? To see how well I could handle the immense pressure of disagreeing with a colleague? Of course. Wouldn’t want any of our classmates to think that you actually just got your ass handed to you BY A GIRL.

4) Fuck off.