Yesterday I listened to a brief section of the Kyle and Jackie-O show (one of the most popular radio shows in Sydney) entitled “Should I stay or should I go”. The caller wondered if he should leave his girlfriend because she had gained some weight and developed stretch marks since they first started dating. Jackie-O responded by accusing the caller of being shallow and superficial. To which, Kyle angrily stated something along the lines of it being unfair now because men “aren’t allowed to have an opinion anymore” and that, because of feminism, men get attacked for “telling the truth.” I can’t exactly remember what else he said, but his general argument was that men are now second class citizens because women have won the right to shoot down things that they say. Here’s the problem (and it’s been bothering me since I heard the show). Jackie-O challenged the content of the caller’s opinion, identifying it as shallow and offensive. Kyle didn’t challenge the content of Jackie-O’s opinion, he challenged her for having an opinion, or daring to voice this opinion, when it opposed a male’s “truth”. The point of free and equal discourse is that men and women can object to each other’s opinions in an open forum (or, indeed, object to the opinions voiced by members of the same gender). If Kyle had said that Jackie-O’s assessment of the caller was erroneous or unfair, there wouldn’t be a problem. They could have had a debate about the validity of judging one’s partner based on appearances, which would have at least made for interesting and balanced radio conversation. But no, Kyle shut Jackie-O down for openly disagreeing the male caller, forcing her to apologise on air for having the audacity to object to the way he perceives his girlfriend. Disappointing.