Jennie Higgins
I was asked to sing a vocal solo at Bristol Cathedral as part of a joint school choir of around 200 students, the solo in questions was the Chichester Psalms by Lenord Berstein (ISBN: 978-1-45840-1582-0) in the second movement. However a month before the performance an issue was found- it is made explicit in the composers comments it is not to be sung by a woman. “The long male-alto solo in the second movement must not be sung by a woman, but either by a boy or a counter-tenor.” I would find no issue with this if it was due to the content of the solo being gender specific, however it is merely “The Lord is My Shepherd” in Hebrew. The excuse given by the conductor was that it was to do with the Jewish religion however it was not planned to be sung in a synagogue but a christian cathedral, and is therefore not insulting to be sung by a young woman. The content of the composers note is also rather sexist in the way it is written, it may have been written in 1965 but should it still be being published by Boosey & Hawkes in 2017?!

























