writing

Maia

I write science fiction. Despite the fact that lots and LOTS of women do, the field is still largely behind older, white, straight male gatekeepers. When I worked as a “slush pile” editor for a sci fi mag, I did my best to put forward the best stories each time. They were often by women, and tread new territory or at least contained elements that spoke to me. I never put forward anything that I considered inferior just to promote the work of women. Maybe that was wrong, because the final magazine always contained work that was predominantly conservative: mostly male or male-identifying characters, female characters absent or passive, and in situations where sexist mores were the norm. Worse (I think), there were a number of stories with female protagonists, often of color, but that also were written by white men! When I questioned the former, I was told that the best stories were always chosen, but it was clear that the criteria for what made a good story either didn’t include or somehow excluded the women writers I put forward, and admitted stories I thought were tired and familiar, with little to recommend them that was fresh or exciting. This industry has a long way to go to even recognize officially that sexism is a problem. It’s easier to fall back on statements about women not liking science, or how we should focus on the science in the story and leave politics for other genres.

Bethany

I am a playwright – have been for over two years and have been lucky enough to have a lot of success. I usually charge $30-$120 to read and give feedback on a play and I know I’m worth every penny. I was invited to give feedback on various plays being read in a workshop. For the first four plays, every time after I spoke with questions or concerns about the piece, a man in the group jumped in and said why I was wrong and why the piece was fine as it was. This is a playwright who has, in the past, sent me creepy and unwanted emails and exhibited other toxic behaviors. Now he was clearly rebutting everything I said, coming across particularly strong to defend the other pays by older, straight, white male playwrights (who were 3/4 of the playwrights I was hearing from). What was worse was when I took the moderator – a woman – aside to draw attention to the fact that this guy was interrupting and undermining me, when I’d specifically been asked to attend and give feedback, she said he probably just wanted people to “feel good” about what they wrote and “he has daughters so he can’t be a sexist.” Good grief.