Was watching an online stop motion animation that was advertising an Afro-American Girl Action Figure. The ad was created by a children’s toy company with a female CEO and showed the Afro-American Girl Action figure taking the lead role in scenes from popular Action Movies.
The tagline reads:
“What if all the action heroes who save the world…were girls?”
Many people commenting on the video identified as male. Many males commenting had valid criticisms of the video such as that it lacked originality (it shamelessly copied existing movies and did not have its own original storyline: it was basically a girl grafted on to pre-existing storylines to replace the lead role). Hence this made the advert rather boring and predictable: which I’d agree. The ad changed the semiotic paradigm by replacing the original white male role in the Action Movies with a female from an ethnic minority.
Lots of men resented the fact that their favourite male lead characters had been replaced by an African-American girl doll, so these men reacted with hostility to the video by posting vitriolic comments, which tainted their valid, observant points about the “unoriginal” storyline. The men put the argument forward that it is mostly the hetero-male demographic that watch and direct action movies, so the movie industry is simply a case of “supply and demand economics”. Some believed that women would prefer to watch “Chick-Flicks” instead of violent movies. Many men suggested that women should stop complaining to them about the lack of female roles in movies and that women should do their own scriptwriting and/or directing. Some men wrote that women were “whiny [expletive referring to women’s private body parts] babies” for not putting the hard work into movie making like the men did. The toy being advertised is part of a product line that actually encourages children to animate, create and direct their own films using smartphone App technology.
Disturbingly, these men included derogatory references to female body parts in their comments and suggested that they wanted to “punch women in the face”. These men exercised their right to freedom of speech without considering that impressionable children and their parents could be watching the video: it was a toy ad. Many men tactlessly swore and mentioned female dogs when talking about women. I sincerely hope that these men would never use such hurtful misogynistic language in front of their children. I may not be a parent, but I realise that children are “like sponges” and copy the language that adults use around them.
Most of the people actually posting constructive criticism without swearing were some of the more polite anti-feminists who rightfully pointed that there are already some female leads in action movies such as in “The Hunger Games” and “Mad Max: Fury Road”.
There were some sensible people who basically said that there should be new stories written for new heroines instead of uncreatively ripping off of pre-existing male dominated storylines/heroes. Also some people commented that an equal number of male and female heroes in movies would promote equality: not all of action movie roles being taken over by women as portrayed in the ad. I agree with point whole-heartedly.
The heated discussion made me wonder about who heroes and heroines really are and how we define them as a society. Heroes are commonly defined as hyper-masculine and muscular. They are often armed and fight for justice.
There are other people in the world who are supposed fight their corners for their clients without using violence: lawyers. Are lawyers heroes/heroines?
Doctors and nurses heal people. People in the emergency services rescue people.
Is a male midwife a hero?
Is a male youth group leader a hero?
What about a female scientist?
There are heroes and villians in schools, teaching, administrating, cooking and emptying the bins.
What about mothers and fathers: are they heroes/heroines?
Heroic action can be quiet and peaceful. It isn’t just all about defending people using violent means.
Here’s a constructive criticism I have about the children’s toy ad: it unfortunately promotes violent adult films to children. For instance the Afro-American girl doll is seen in the middle of a 007 style “gun barrel” sequence’. The gun barrel in the toy advert has been styled to look like a camera aperture (the young female African American computer programmer role-model is a keen photographer). I personally think that this sequence was a mistake and sends the wrong message to children about what films they are legally allowed to watch. This is unfortunate given the creative original animation produced by the toy company in the past. Also, having a girl in every frame may give girls an unhealthy sense of entitlement that they should dominate every facet of their lives without letting the boys have a go. There are no boys or girls working together in the ad: one girl does everything herself, which sends a very one sided message.
There, I tactfully expressed my opinion about toy advert without having to resort to women making sandwiches jokes, references to private female body parts, threatening women with physical violence or hateful misogynistic slurs.

























