Peter

How many times have you seen a drama, often the basis of a television series, but also in film, in which the male and female leads have a tense working relationship because she, whilst brilliant, dedicated, ambitious and driven, is also sober, uptight, humourless, priggish, overly cautious and fails to take risks. He on the other hand will also be brilliant, but the fact that he is uncouth, brash, risk-taking, careless, arrogant, selfish and thoughtless are meant to be charming, sexy and admirable? The ‘will-they / won’t they’ relationship that underpins the tension between the characters is always about him ‘thawing’ her out, and winning her over to his way of thinking despite herself. It’s never about him being forced to deal with the consequences of his own irresponsibility and being won over by her faultless competence. That’s just another way the ‘Bechdel Test’ is routinely failed, even where there are ‘strong’ or ‘feminist’ archetypes, because the male archetype is always right, whereas the woman who has battled to make her way in a man’s world still doesn’t really understand what she’s doing, and despite being cleverer than the male, still forced to learn the way of the world from him.

The Bechdel test is used to identify gender bias in fiction. A work passes the test if it features at least two women who talk to each other about something other than a man. Commentators have noted that a great proportion of contemporary works fail to pass this threshold of representing women. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bechdel_test . How low is this threshold? And yet, can you think of the last time something you watched / read passed it?

Cinema has gone so far backwards. “His Girl Friday” and “The Philadelphia Story” were made in the ’30’s and ’40’s, and yet the premise of both films is that Cary Grant, through his selfishness and irresponsibility has been divorced by his wife, who would rather not be under his shadow, and only wins her back when he can demonstrate to her that her own professional and personal fulfilment are his new priority. Watch them now, and what might shock and disturb you is that no film about marriage or relationships produced in English in the last 30 years or so has been as ‘feminist’.