To the whistling heterosexual male –
I’d like for you to help me understand something, as a female. Contrary to potentially popular belief, I do not mean this in a patronizing or condescending manner in the slightest. I just genuinely don’t understand. Why do you catcall?
Is it to make a woman feel pretty? I can’t speak for all women, but when you catcall me, I don’t feel pretty. Noticed? Yes. And I’ll be the first one to admit that sometimes being noticed is nice on the days when one feels invisible. But pretty? No, I don’t feel pretty when you catcall me. So why do you do it?
Is it to show off to your friends? What if they aren’t there? I’m strolling down the street and I get catcalled, but there is no one there besides you and me. No friends to impress, no ladies to make jealous. Why do you do it?
Is it to feel powerful? To feel like your wish is my command – that if you catcall me, I’ll be put underneath your spell of attention and give you a fighting chance? Has catcalling a woman ever actually given you a fighting chance with her? I’ve never met someone who it has worked on, but maybe I’m not hanging out around the right crowd. So why?
I am indeed curious why you catcall. It would satisfy a point of intellectual curiosity for me, and I’d genuinely like to hear your take on it. But you know what? At the end of the day, I could not care less why you do it. I care that you do it. And I want you to stop. I demand that you stop.
When I walk by you on the street, and you hoot and holler, or whistle, or give me the 1,000 mile stare, or point and whisper to your friends – when you do all that, I don’t feel scared, or ashamed, or like my skirt is too short, or my blouse too revealing. I feel annoyed. Plain and simple, your antics are annoying as hell and interrupt my day. I’m tired of being followed, of your hands reaching out as I walk by so that I have to cut a path around you to avoid you copping a feel, of having to switch subway cars because to be frank, being intensely stared at is damn awkward and pisses me off before my morning coffee. I’m tired of sitting at Dunkin Donuts and ignoring you as you come up to the glass window next to me and dance around like a drunken clown, trying to get my attention. Newsflash for the catcalling, whistling, heterosexual male: it’s annoying, and makes you look infantile. No woman wants to be with a man like that.
Sometimes, when you speak to me, saying, hey baby I didn’t mean to startle you, how ya doin today, I respond with a terse, you didn’t startle me, I’m just walking to work. Sometimes I say nothing at all and pretend like my music is too loud and I didn’t hear, even if you are standing right in front of me. Sometimes I start speaking a different language and you leave, confused, and I feel a moment of victory in having perplexed and outwitted you.
Societal wisdom and wives tales and my mother all tell me that ignoring your sort is the most effective way to deal with you. Well I’d just like to ask one thing: since you clearly seem to be unable to ignore me, and go out of your way to make that known, why should I have to ignore you? If you are going to intentionally piss me off, the least I can do is return the favor, and maybe question your behavior in the process. I’m not aiming to be vengeful; I’m just aiming to make it known that I cannot simply be trounced upon like a doormat. I’m not aiming to degrade you or make you feel bad about yourself, I’m aiming to challenge you to ask yourself if your behavior is something you are proud of as a man. Because it seems to me that you take my silence for complacency. And I, for one, am not complacent.
Societal wisdom and wives tales still tell me that I should ignore you. That if I fire back a wittily aggressive comment, or responded as one of your bros might if you tried some version of this shit on them, with a noncommittal fuck off, asshole, that you’d get off on it, or find it exciting, or be one of the crazies that does something drastic like pull a weapon on me, or kidnap me, or assault me. It seems to me that society is telling me that I should operate from a place of fear in regards to you, because you might try to harm me. To society at large, I ask you: how are we ever supposed to break gender stereotypes if you are telling my gender to operate from a place of fear? I refuse to do it anymore. Callous, you say?
I have very little left to be afraid of.
When you have been sexually assaulted by 7 different people in 3 separate incidents, you start to believe that lightning can strike twice, and you stop being so afraid. Oh yes, the triggers and the PTSD and the nightmares are awful and life shattering, and seem to strike at random sometimes. But having lived through it once, twice, and then a third time, in a variety of settings and at a variety of ages, I’ve learned that fear is not going to make any difference one way or another. Sometimes one is simply in the wrong place at the wrong time. So I choose not to be afraid, and to ignore you out of fear. It doesn’t serve either of us, or society, in the end.
I have done my best not to generalize on the part of women or men – to speak as myself, from my experience, to an anonymous whistling heterosexual male who could be anyone, and who comes in many different varieties. But if you are that anonymous whistling heterosexual male, and you feel stereotyped or generalized about by this article? Just consider the way any woman you catcall might feel, and the fact that a lot of those stereotypes would go away if you’d stop conforming to them. So the next time you pass me on the street? Ignore me. It would mean a better morning for all of us.
Sincerely,
Sofia Peretti*
*name has been changed to respect the privacy of the writer’s family

























