Anon

Many years ago, lots of girls turned up to an after school Engineering Club open evening taster session. They appeared to be having lots of fun working together making rubber band motors and talking to people. One of the bottles with a rubber band motor “breakdanced” across the floor and the girls laughed: they thought it was hilarious.

At the open evening, there was a retired welder who had been invited to teach welding at the club. He turned away girls from his display stand and would only let the boys talk to him. When I tried to ask him questions about welding, he frowned at me and told me to do electronics instead. I am female. I was eventually shunted into the electronics group. My parents were somehow persuaded that this would be better for me.

This after school Engineering Club was embarrassing for me to attend for several reasons:

-I was the only girl that showed up for the real club the week after the taster session. The boys often snickered at me.

-I was ignored in class. The male electronics teacher would ask me if I was lost or if I was actually meant to be in his room. I had to point to my name in the register to prove that I had been signed up. After this, the teacher would forget what my name was and wonder why I was in his class. He seemed more comfortable talking to the boys.

-My male teacher was badly organised and left me alone with 20 boys while he went to make umpteen cups of coffee. He let us roam around the empty school on our own at night. He didn’t make lesson plans. Everything he did was ad-hoc: he ended up doing all of the soldering of the circuit board while we watched him. All the programming of the robot was done by older male students who had studied programming outside of the club.

-My teacher gave a clipboard to me and asked me to take notes while the boys actually got to build the robot and physically test it out.

-My teacher had no teacher training in classroom management and his teaching was poor, which meant that many people didn’t understand what he said. It’s a shame because he was a nice, quiet, friendly person otherwise. He said: “Talk amongst yourselves…” every time he ran out of ideas.

-My teacher was indifferent and ignored my enthusiasm towards the subject, which really decreased my motivation.

The main reason that the Engineering Club was embarrassing for me was because it made me the butt of jokes by my peers that didn’t go to the club. A lot of people, particularly girls, would ask me why I was “wasting” my time with studying boring robots with boring boys when I could be going out with friends, watching TV or playing sport.

They also cruelly suggested that I wasn’t attending the club to learn about engineering at all, but that I was going to be around lots of boys for “romantic” reasons. They also said that the boys there weren’t exactly very charismatic or attractive looking, so they said they were puzzled as to why I wanted to hook up with “boys like that”. They couldn’t fathom that I might actually be going to the club because I wanted to try and learn something new: not purely for social reasons. They made fun of me because I was the only girl in a “boys’ club”. The people who didn’t go to the club ridiculed me for actually taking an active interest in “boy things”.

A curious thing that I noticed (which baffles me to this day) was that most of the jokes and criticism I endured came from girls that attended that first open evening taster session of the after school Engineering Club, but then dropped out!

How come that these girls changed their minds from thinking:
“Technology is funny and exciting!” at the open evening taster session to…
“Technology is boring and a waste of time with boring boys.”?

It makes me feel sad. Were those girls honestly faking enjoying themselves at the taster evening or did the welding teacher put them off with his boy favouring attitude?

Was it the fact that all of the Engineering teachers were male and weren’t charismatic enough for the girls? Was it because there were no female Engineers to act as role models for girls at the club?

Was it because the evening club may have clashed with the girls’ sporting commitments such as cross-country running and netball fixtures?

Was it because the club was on in the evening when the girls’ favourite TV shows were on (this was in the days of VCR recording before the internet and Sky+)?

Was it because, if one girl decided she wasn’t going, then the rest of her friends decided that they weren’t going because they wouldn’t go if their friends didn’t go?

Did the girls not go due to peer pressure from other boys and girls?

Was it because the girls’ parents were too tired to take them at night after initially thinking that it would be a good idea for their daughters to learn about engineering?

Was it because the girls baby sat and already had family/friend commitments that they could not get out of?

Was it because the girls already had a lot of homework/musical instrument practice homework/school play scripts that they had to study which meant that they didn’t have time to go to the club?

This would be a good topic for Sociology Research:
“Why do girls drop out of after school Technology Clubs?”
Sadly, I am not a Sociologist and do not have the money to fund such a study, so perhaps I’ll never really know why those girls dropped out: it’ll be forever a perplexing mystery.

I did not learn much at the badly organised Engineering Club. I am not an Engineer now and I am not an “inspiration” to anyone. The Club was very isolating and led to people (especially girls) teasing me because of my gender. I do not have a high paying job now. I am a volunteer worker who isn’t formally in a technical field. The club didn’t help me succeed at all. The only thing good that I learned was how to work with males and tolerate their behaviour.

This is why it makes me angry to see lots of young women take part in after School Engineering Clubs and work together whilst learning a lot from female teachers. I feel bitter and sad because I never had the supportive environment that they had. Some engineering clubs are just for girls and I never had access to this either. When I see girls saying that they are inspired to be engineers because of an all girl after school engineering or welding club, I feel sick to my stomach. I feel jealous, sad and angry all at the same time. I hate feeling this way.

It was such a waste, the after school Engineering Club could have helped me and other girls if it had been run properly and supported women without excluding them.

What a waste of enthusiasm and talent!

Some Girls’ Only after School Technology Clubs may not be all that good though.

It makes me angry when I see “pinkified” girls only after School Technology and Coding Clubs advertised that pander to girls’ supposed interests in make-up, gossip, fashion and music celebrities.

Such approaches would mean that the capable “tom-boyish” “Spinelli’s” of the world would run out of the “girly” club room screaming. Maybe some girls would like to learn stuff from boys or may have interests that stupid society considers as “boyish”?

Girls Only Clubs may create “pink ghettos” for girls where they cannot interact with boys and share ideas. Also this is bad preparation for male dominated technology and engineering fields that are male dominated: girls need to get used to working with males early so it isn’t a culture shock when they have to later on.

As a secondary school girl student, I had zero interest in make-up or fashion or gossiping. Such an approach would have alienated me. I hate it when I’m made to feel rotten because I think make up is stupid and superficial. Not all girls like girly things: shock horror, some girls may actually want to do practical things and wear practical clothes for this!

It also bothers me when these all girl-learning programmes are supposedly tailored to “girls’ learning styles”, the “female brain” and “co-operative group working”. Cordelia Fine critiques the idea that there is one universal kind of “female brain”: her meta-analysis is strangely not put into consideration when designing all girls technology clubs. I am female and have always preferred to work alone, which led some twits to try and diagnose me with social or learning disorders because solitary working and quiet thinking are pathologised. Some girls can be intensely competitive in sport, dance, academics, drama and playing video games. Why is it taboo to consider that some girls may want to compete against each other and not always co-operate?

If some girls want to programme a make-up or fashion video game, let them, just don’t expect every last girl who’s interested in technology to fall in line with gendered expectations. Some girls might want to program a video game featuring mutated slimy toads firing lasers at robots, then enter it into a competition. Let them for goodness sake! Let girls have a choice; don’t just shove them into a “girly” socially conditioned box. Let them be creative and technical in their own individual ways. Let them have individual support.