Grown-a**-woman

I am a practicing lawyer, have been for 16 years. I was in court regarding where a 3 year old boy should live I raised an issue to the white, male judge about the mothers current boyfriend and the fact that the police had been called to the mothers home because of a domestic dispute. I brought up the fact that mother had been arrested along with the child’s father for domestic violence. The judge interrupted me to ask whether the charges against mother were dropped. He knew they were already. I said yes but I did not know the reason, whether the father refused to testify against her or the prosecutor decided not to pursue it. The judge asked whether there was any evidence that the mother was anything other than a victim of domestic violence. I said yes, the police observed injuries on the father. The judge then asked me “doesn’t a woman have the right to defend herself.”

I stood silent for a few seconds because I couldn’t believe he was asking me-a female attorney- whether women have the right to defend themselves from domestic violence? Was he actually expecting an answer? Did he think I would say anything other than “yes”? Clearly a sarcastic question.

I answered that I’m not in court to debate with him whether a woman has a right to defend herself. I know women have a right to defend themselves because I’ve done it. I’m raising the issue to the court that mothers previous and now current relationships have instances of domestic violence and the court needs to know about it before saying a 3 year-old should go live in that home where DV might be going on. I said that is my job to raise questions for the court to look into and I was doing my job. Then I sat down.

First of all, I do NOT need a 60-something year-old white man to mansplain women’s safety concerns to me. Haven’t countless women had to do it in some way, whether in a big way or small way? Walking with keys in your hand at night. Being followed on a city street and told to smile and why don’t you smile when someone compliments you? Having your legal career threatened by the married man whose romantic advances you politely declined and trying to figure out not to end up having to leave your job (which I had to do btw).

Second, women can be guilty of domestic violence too. Don’t put women in a category that we can only be the victims. Woman can be the victims and women can be the perpetrators. Women can be good and women can be bad. Women are not statues on a pedestal that can never be in the wrong.

I was doing my job to make sure a young child would not be sent into a home with domestic violence. No matter WHO was the perpetrator, no child should live in that environment. And I got women’s rights mansplained to me.
Thanks “Judge”. I needed that lesson obviously.