This week, I had a discussion with a friend of mine about gendered pronouns. He is a nice, normally thoughtful guy, and I tend to value his arguments and opinions. We were discussing a text in which philosophers in general were described as “the philosopher[…], HE should be mindful to[…]”, which I found to be biased and excluding to female philosophers.
When another participant in this conversation mentioned that she finds it really pleasant when people take the trouble to add the phrasing “he or she”, I added that perhaps “them/they” was even more neutral, not to mention more brief and comprehensive. I also mentioned the gender neutral pronouns xe/xem. My friend suddenly started laughing, calling such pronouns “unaesthetic” and “unnecessary”, as he experienced a generic “he” as being inclusive enough. Yet he objected to using a generic “she”, which he thought to be over the top, despite the fact that about 51% of the world’s population is female.
What followed was an extensive discussion, which I will not go into here, but I was quite shocked about his easy dismissal of xe/xem, and even the them/they I suggested. He did hit the nail on the head when he suggested that maybe such things didn’t really bother him because he was male. It’s so easy to feel included when you’re the default straight, highly educated, white, cis-gendered male. Things are, regrettably, rather different for the rest of us, and I really resented his lack of empathy.

























