Anon

Let me start off by saying that I am a woman. As a woman I have nothing against other women with expertise in the fields of science or technology passing on their knowledge to other women and girls. I have nothing against practical mentoring of women and girls for real world tasks. I honestly wish there would be more women with expertise teaching women and girls and showing them what can be done by women.

I have absolutely nothing against women and girls of low social and economic status being taught how to use a computer or code. This would be great if they took the lead in the creative process themselves.

What I am against is the very patronising advertising campaigns that use the word “empowerment” to reinforce existing stereotypes about females by using pink, make-up, hearts, fashion, flowers and glitter as hooks to try and sell technology to girls and women. A lot of these campaigns seem to be designed by male inventors and videographers to try and encourage women to get involved in technology.

One such supposedly “empowering” advertising campaign was for a girls’ construction kit. The advert was amazing to look at: it seemed as though little girls from different backgrounds had designed a complex machine all by themselves with the aid of the pink and purple construction kit plus a pink feather boa, a pink tea set and a pink baby carrier.

If you look at the behind the scenes videos of how the advert was made however, you quickly realise that the contraption was actually put together by male inventors. Also, all of the camera work and video editing was done by men. The complex chain reaction is edited to look like it’s one continuous shot. It’s not. The girls are just actresses who are told where to go and what to do by the men. They don’t get to build the machine themselves, they just watch the men do it all for them! The girls watch the men work out all of the physics, the girls do not design the machine themselves! So basically, it’s like buying a construction kit, watching your Dad, male cousins and brothers put it all together for you, then taking all of the credit for yourself (“Girl Power Rah rah rah! Look at what I made!”). This is very lazy and deceptive methinks and is a bad message to send to young women. Men are not there to be used to do practical hard work while girls just sit back and watch!

Lots of men watching the “behind the scenes” of the advert on the internet are laughing because they see this as “proof” that only men can really design and build machines and that girls are lazy. Boys and men see the “irony” behind the ad, which wasn’t as the people in the company intended!

This ad, when viewed in conjunction with the “behind the scenes” footage is sexist towards both men and women because:
-It assumes that girls are incapable and stupid: they have to get the “big boys” to build things for them because they are technologically inept
-It assumes that men are there to be used by lazy women and girls to do practical technology while the girls take all of the credit for the men’s hard work for themselves!

The discontinued “girl empowering” Barbie book “I can be a computer engineer” seemed to have similar sexist messages.

A lot of these “girls empowerment” campaigns assume that all girls like pretty hearts, flowers and stars without exception. These campaigns assume that girls don’t like all those “nasty horrid boy” colours such as red, blue, green or black, but must have everything made for them in pink! The girls often have to wear pink T-Shirts with the campaign empowerment slogan, as if passers by couldn’t tell that the girls were girls just by looking at them. What about girls who are Goths or happen to like the colour blue or hate hearts and flowers? Well, I guess that these so called “girls empowerment” campaigns aren’t for all girls then LOL!

A lot of these campaigns claim to be designed for girls based on how the “female brain” supposedly thinks! Decorating supposedly “horrid nasty boy” technology with pretty hearts and flowers, then colouring everything pink based on some questionable “scientific” research is incredibly patronising towards girls and women.

I have nothing against the colour pink, however, I am against people assuming that all girls and women like it without exception! Some women don’t like pink! Hearts and flowers and glitter look nice, however they are not everyone’s or every female’s cup of tea! This kind of décor might be appropriate for “Care-a-lot”, but it’s not appropriate for what some girls and women may want to do with their lives!

Lots of girls “empowerment” campaigns assume that Science is a “nasty boring boy subject” which is supposedly why girls and women are put off studying it. So, to encourage girls to become scientists, one “genius” videographer decided that girls might like science if it was all about fashion and make up. A “girl empowering” advert was created where the “i” in the word “science” was replaced by lipstick. Words and equations were written in lipstick (because women are supposedly too stupid to use a pen dontcha know? Sarcasm). Health and safety were thrown out of the window as the female scientists strutted about like models in high heels giggling and playfully throwing molecules into the air. They were clearly flirting with the male scientist (who was trying to concentrate on doing his microscope work, but he was clearly distracted by the young women). The result is a farcical looking “cosmetics advert”, which may or may not have been based on a male “scientist’s” “fantasy”.

I am sorry, but when I have been told by people that they will “empower” me, they have never taken my opinions or my life circumstances into account: they have just wittered on about their own utopian fantasies of how they want me to be then ask for my money at the end. “Empowering” disabled and “mentally ill” people by sugar coating reality and saying platitudes like “You can do anything if you try!” (regardless of circumstances, money, other people’s attitudes, whether the building has a ramp, how ill you are or how much you hurt etc…) is just as asinine as some of these pink drenched “girl empowerment” campaigns. As I found out, if you’re not constantly upbeat or inspiring to others, you get a lot of hate from carers and social workers! This enforced positivity probably runs rife in “girls empowerment workshops” leaving no room for struggle, sadness and real life commitments! A lot of women’s cancer support “empowerment” groups have become patronisingly pinkified enforcing “positivity” even when situations are hopeless. I have heard that women can be rejected from these groups if they don’t smile enough.

Call building a ramp what it is: building a ramp, not “empowering disabled people”. Give the person in a wheelchair who powered his/her way up the slope some credit! A ramp is just a tool (a simple machine in fact): it takes a person to make it work! Give a girl the credit when she builds a machine or uses a tool: the word “empowerment” “bigs up” the workshop organisers and ignores the girls’ individual hard work!

Empowered people are “acted upon” by the people “empowering” them.
Powerful people are actors who use their power.

In the nineties songs and people would say: “I’ve got the power!”, but nowadays people are so weak that they have to be “empowered” by someone else before they can do anything! (especially girls, because boys apparently never have to be “empowered”). Girls have to have their “hands held” by being “empowered” while boys have to struggle on their own to learn things. Infantilising to girls and women much?

Bring back the nineties attitudes!
Bring back a time when girls and boys had to learn about technology in clubs together!
Bring back individual power and agency!
Bring back the “Tom-boy” who works things out on her own and has no need for a pink world of flowers, hearts or butterflies!

The phrase “empowering girls to build robots” takes the credit away from the girls who worked hard to build the robot or code the computer, and credits the teachers for all of the girls’ hard work!

The phrase “the girls worked hard to build their machines to their own designs, after they were trained by mentors” emphasises the hard work that the girls put into their projects. It shows that the girls have agency.

I dislike the word “empower” because it implies that the system is okay and that the girls, women and/or disabled people have to be “changed” to fit the dysfunctional system by “empowerers”. The disabled people and girls are shunted into teaching “ghettos” with people like themselves. The girls are all herded together so they don’t have to compete with those “nasty horrid competitive boys”! Or heaven forbid, share any ideas with those supposedly “nasty horrid competitive boys”!

What about the girl who tinkers around in her garage alone and build a car without a “female empowerment” workshop? Is she any less powerful than those that attend the workshop if she figures things out for herself without it all being spoon-fed to her wrapped in a pretty pink bow?

In my opinion, the word “empower” should be placed in “Room 101” and the “Dustbin of History”. It is a meaningless buzz-word that allows people to stereotype women and girls by shunting them into a “pink feminine” box while ignoring their individuality and creativity. There is nothing wrong with feminine women who like pink: there is everything wrong with expecting all women to act feminine and like pink.

Instead of vacuous buzzwords such as the “e” word, use real meaningful words such as “training”, “mentoring”, “activism”, “making”, “experimenting”, “building”, “programming” and “teaching. These are real words with no fancy pink metaphysics attached.

Real women and girls need real help so that they can develop their own ideas individually. Non-condescending real world physical and logistical help. Women who are already interested in science and technology need useful mentoring, not a lot of pink “hot air”.

As a woman I don’t feel “empowered” and I’m glad. I failed at what I was going to do, so I’m no inspiration to anybody.
Even so, I am glad that I wasn’t subjected to a sea of pink and forced to smile like some of these “empowered” young women are being forced to.

Being told that I was being “empowered” as a “female mentally ill person” did squat all for me. It would have honestly been more useful if someone got a chocolate teapot and tried to pour me some hot tea out of it.

Also, girls may be enthusiastic about science and technology now, but what will happen to them later on when they have to work with men, have to deal with family commitments, deal with rejection, look after disabled relatives and depression hits?

Reality doesn’t look quite so pink and full of sparkly hearts, flowers and butterflies now does it?