Went out for coffee with friends who all happened to be girls a few weekends ago. While deliberating over whether or not to have a cake, the man behind the counter a) assumed I was deliberating because of guilt over whether or not to allow myself to eat something that might cause me to put on weight and b) felt this was so normalised and widespread an assumption that it was ok for him to bring it up and jokily give me his permission in a ‘go on, you look fine’ sort of way.
This, on the face of it isn’t a big deal – it’s exactly the kind of thing men who get grumpy when you talk about inequality and claim it’s all a big illusion would be cross about my even mentioning.
But let’s break down the social assumptions and norms that had to be present in order for this to happen.
1) All women are judged on their body shape, are aware of this and are worrying constantly about their body shape.
2) Women’s body shapes are there to be publically judged, so there is absolutely nothing wrong with appraising and commenting on them publically.
3) A woman’s concern with her worth, as judged by society only on the basis of her appearence, must naturally take precedence over her own desires and pleasures in her order of priorities.
4) A man has the position, afforded by society, of authority over a woman he has never even met before, purely on the basis of their gender alone, to grant her the ‘permission’ to eat something that may affect her shape. This heavily implies not only the subservience of women to men, but also the assumption that our consideration of our figures is purely for men’s benefit and therefore makes us succumb to their authority in any issue or question relating to that consideration.
Then I asked myself some other questions – would these things ever have been said to a man? No, for 2 reasons.
1) The original assumption of a man’s value being based on his body and subsequent assumptions about his obsession with his body wouldn’t be triggered.
2) It might be considered ‘rude’ or ‘weird’ for the guy behind the counter to comment on another man’s weight.
Then I wondered whether, in that case, the man behind the counter would have made the same comment to me had I been in a group that included men, or perhaps with my boyfriend. It’s not impossible, but I concluded it was much less likely. This led me to ruminate that:
1) There is a hugely prevalent belief in society that men have the right to address women however they choose including in cases involving intimate and personal comments about their appearence and sexuality. (Witness frequent street catcalling).
2) Men still consider other men to have ‘ownership’ or rights over women they happen to be with in public to such an extent that they will frequently significantly change their behaviour towards these women when in the company of a man – also reducing women’s own autonomy and independence.
This might sound over-exaggerated but I truly believe that all of these extremely normalised underlying social assumptions had to be in place for this apparently innocuous and unimportant event to occur. And, of course, as a woman, it then continues the cycle by reaffirming to me the principles that yes, men are constantly looking at, judging and valuing me on the basis of my figure, yes, it is socially assumed that I will be carefully restricting my calorie intake accordingly, yes, being thinner is ‘better’ and yes, a man I have never met before, even in the socially subservient position of providing me with a service, has the right and the absolute confidence in that right to make personal, judgemental and condescending comments to me wherever I go.

























