Anon

Saw some online video reviews on a mobile “Game for Girls” app. You basically do physical exercises while being called “Hey fatty!” by a male personal trainer cartoon character. I don’t need an buy an app for that thanks: I already get called “fat” IRL so I don’t need reminding by some fat shaming virtual bloke. It would be a complete waste of money.

Some of the phrases in the “Game for Girls” seemed eerily familiar because they had been used on me by members of my own family, particularly a male relative. Just like the male character in the game, he would call me “chubby” and comment on how much I’d eaten for breakfast. I was shocked at how reviewers for the game had called comments like these that the male cartoon character made “verbally abusive” and “self esteem damaging”. I got these types of comments every day from my male relative so I thought that this was totally normal. I had to just say “sorry that I’m fat” to everything he said. He was overweight himself which made the situation so awkward and ironic. He didn’t listen to anyone, he just talked at people.

During my adolescence, my male relative kept commenting on how thick with fat my “thunder thighs” and hips were. Every time he looked at me, he would always comment on my weight. I got called “greedy guts ache” and he’d make snorting pig noises when I tried to eat. His wife and daughter were subjected to this too. They were told that they had “let themselves go” by him and that they were “fat and ugly”. Women strangers didn’t escape this treatment either. He’d say:
“Oh look there goes cream cakes!” as he looked at a dancer on stage. He said that every time she danced. Every year for the same show he’d refer to her as “cream cakes” with fat bits wobbling about.

In his youth, my male relative had even called a young girl “fatty”. He got so annoyed with her that she was hurt by a well aimed arrow shot during one of his childhood “Cowboys and Indians” games. The girl survived, but my male relative was punished by his parents. He didn’t do it again. This didn’t stop him from retelling the “fatty girl” story years later.

My male relative constantly makes comments about “fat people”, especially overweight women and how “stupid” they are for being fat. Ironically, he’d do this while stuffing down several packets of crisps. He says that crisps are “slimming” because they are thin. Then he’d complain about how fat he was, then complain about how fat I or other female members of my family were. He wasn’t really into the whole “emotional support” thing. In PSHE, it was recommended that I talked about “body imagine issues” with close family. It would have been an absolute bloody waste of time talking with my male relative about body imagine issues. He wasn’t sensitive about anybody’s feelings. He’d just come straight out with the unfiltered statement “you’re fat and lazy”. Or “you’re such an ugly fat cow”.

He’d tell me to “run faster faster, you’re too slow!” like an impatient drill sergeant so that I can “burn the weight off”. Should have rented my male relative out to people who wanted to lose weight so they could listen to him ramble about how “fatty” they were instead of some virtual bloke on a “jokey” app. Missed business opportunity.

I didn’t read any teenage or women’s magazines when I was growing up: I didn’t have to read about losing weight because my male relative kept telling me to lose weight constantly.

The grand prize at the end of the “burn fat” “Game for Girls” app is a kiss from a virtual negging bloke. I have known female friends and relatives who lost weight through exercise because they wanted to do it for themselves so that they could feel good, not because of the reward of a one-sided relationship from some virtual prince tactless personal trainer. They pushed themselves to exercise: no virtual bloke personal trainer required.

Some women probably think that a simulated kiss from a virtual bloke would probably make all of the bullying, back-handed compliments and harassment worthwhile. Maybe they think that such behaviour would be cute and motivating. I would just find it as annoying and pathetic as my male relative constantly complaining about fat women. All the while him saying: “I’m trying to help you not be fat”. Ugh.

Maybe the whole “body acceptance” movement hasn’t yet reached Asia (where the game was originally made) or my house for that matter. I suppose in Asia they expect all women to look like super thin models I guess, judging from all of the plastic surgery and people over there constantly trying to lose weight. Not saying that losing some weight is a bad idea, however, one can become overly obsessive about these things.

It is scary though how almost all the exact same words that a male relative said to me about “fat” appear in an Asian video game. When you hear someone constantly moaning about how “fat” you are IRL you just tune out. The thoughtless comments make you tougher though and you grow a thicker skin because of it, but you can’t interact with the person calling you “fat” in any mutually beneficial way. Talking to the person calling you “fat” is like banging your head against a proverbial brick wall. It hurts. My male relative’s daughter dealt with my male relative’s derogatory comments by singing “la la la” and covering her hands with her ears. If that didn’t work she’d tell him to f*** off and go stuff his opinions “where the sun don’t shine”.

This is why the “body positivity” and “self esteem” movements for girls mentioned in PSHE have always been utterly baffling to me.

My male relative would call me “chubby cheeks” when I came home from school, say I was “rubbish” at doing such and such then he would criticise my Science test scores. One time I got 98%. He asked me:
“What happened to the other 2% ?”
Then he called me “lazy and careless” for not getting full marks. I theoretically could have one a thousand gold medals and a million prizes: he still would have managed to find some fault with my performances. I feel guilty that I didn’t live up to his challenging standards though. I felt like I had failed as a student and failed to take care of my own body properly.
When I told him that his comments made me feel upset he’d say that I was miserable for taking his guilt tripping “jokes” too seriously.

Some men expect perfection from women.
I tried so hard, but sadly could not deliver to meet their high expectations.
I feel like a failure as a woman and as a daughter.

Virtual blokes are one thing, but some blokes IRL constantly scrutinise and comment on your weight if you are a woman.

Some men think that “fat” women are a joke and are fair game for nasty comments.

Why?