For “Male” who believes that women applicants to his program are getting a boost since 80% of the applicants are male but the gender breakdown for acceptance is 50/50. Your assumption that the applicants are equal is faulty. In my many years of reading grad applications there is a big gender difference: many more weak applications from men. Why? My interpretation is that it takes much less for men to think they’re good enough to go to grad school and to imagine a future PHD, career as a professor. In contrast, because of sexism, women need higher grades, more confidence to think they’re good enough to even apply.
There are many good applicants if both sexes and we cannot accept very many, but the absolute weakest students are always (white) men—and they may be great people but part of their privilege is believing in their own value and their right to grad school regardless of whether they have ever shown the grades or aptitude.

























