B

At my little sister’s 16th birthday I overheard an exchange between two of her friends which still upsets me now, a few years later.

A boy started asking a girl whether she had any ‘sick little fantasies’, about being ‘chased and thrown down’ or ‘saying no, but he doesn’t stop’. She was very obviously very uncomfortable, and made some short response like ‘you watch way too much porn’.

As far as I know it ended there, but I still find it startling and upsetting that anyone would ever speak to someone – let alone someone they consider a friend – in that way. I think it was supposed to be edgily funny; it wasn’t.

I was conscious of not wanting to white-knight it by jumping to the rescue; the girl in question had handled it really well, had both shut the unfunny threatener down and been kinda funny herself. As an older male – and the brother of the host – I felt that anything I might add would be outweighed by my taking over her fight, as though I thought she couldn’t handle it herself. Nonetheless, I caught her eye shortly after and said “what the fuck is his problem?” to make it clear that I wasn’t onside with his behaviour.

And, for better or worse, I ended up catching him alone for a word later when the party was wrapping up. I asked him was he the one who’d been asking the girl about rape fantasies earlier. He was uncomfortable, but said yes he was. I think he was expecting me to ask him did he think it was funny (to which the answer would have been ‘yes, why don’t you lighten up’), as he was surprised when I asked next did he know anyone – male or female – who had been raped or assaulted. He said no. I asked was he sure? Did he think that someone would feel comfortable telling him if they were? He didn’t answer immediately, so I left it there.

I’m aware this might not have been the right course to take, but so much of the sexism recounted here is made worse by the complicity of those who should least be complicit; friends, family, partners. And the line of reasoning I adopted was intended to avoid a confrontation between the two of us as ALPHA MEN (with chest thumping and antler locking); if he thinks again, it will hopefully not be because I HAVE A PROBLEM WITH HIM, but hopefully based on the possible consequences of putting disturbing, aggressive speech out there.