Anon

I recently came back from a large metal festival in Germany and one of the bands I was looking forward to seeing was Xxxxxxx*. They aren’t one of my all-time favourites but I do like some of their songs. Their gimmick as a band is to recreate the 1980s glam-rock/hair metal era and their whole image and sound is distinctly tongue-in-cheek. They deliberately write what some would consider to be ‘shocking’ lyrics, mainly centring around their own purported sexual prowess, but the point is to satirise the macho-culture of a lot of classic ‘80s metal bands such as Motley Crue. It’s what they’re all about and they are essentially a comedy band; not to be taken seriously.

However, when they played at the festival, Xxxxxxx* took the whole ‘80s vibe back in completely the wrong manner; right back to the bloody Dark Ages. They would point out young women in the crowd, who the cameras would then zoom in on, and address them with such charming comments as:
“I bet you’re a whore. You look like a slut.” Meanwhile the women themselves, under the scrutiny of a field of circa 45,000 people [not including the countless thousands watching the performance live on the internet], could only simper and laugh. Whether or not they enjoyed the attention is not the point. After a few rounds of these sorts of comments between songs, Xxxxxxx* began to urge specially-selected women in the crowd to take their tops off and “get [their] tits out”. The whole field was rammed with an audience that was around 70% male and the pressure on these girls was almost tangible. Under the pressure they obliged, which stirred the crowd up into a frenzy and other girls promptly joined in (I’d speculate for reasons ranging from wanting to feel involved, to competing with each other but who knows…).

For the last couple of songs the band encouraged young women to get up on stage with them. Most of the ones who did were already topless and those who weren’t soon became so in order to fit in with the others. The girls were egged on to dance seductively alongside the band. At one point the lead singer went up to one of them with the mic and asked,
“So, what’s your name?” holding it up for her to speak into. Before she could reply he whipped the mic away, quipping, “it doesn’t matter.” Cue big laughs from the crowd.

The whole show made me feel distinctly uncomfortable: Xxxxxxx* were quite blatantly encouraging men to view women as sex objects, and what was worse, creating a pressurised environment that made women feel as if they had to play up to this stereotype. How would it have looked if one of the women the cameras had zoomed in on (her face on 30ft screens, watched by literally thousands) had shaken her head and simply refused to take her top off for the band? She would have been booed, publicly humiliated, and made to feel as if she was a ‘kill-joy’ or ‘prude’ for not obliging. Whereas those who did oblige only exposed themselves to judgemental scrutiny of their physiques (men in the crowd making loud, lewd comments about whose bodies were better than others) and general disrespect – being lumped together as ‘Xxxxxxx*’s “easy” girls’ rather than a selection of individual women with their own motivations, histories and intelligence.

Another outcome of the scenario I described was that it noticeably primed the crowd to think of women in a derogatory way. Following Xxxxxxx*’s set I was aware that the men surrounding me began looking at me and all the other women around in a much more overt and predatory manner. It didn’t feel safe and I was glad I was with a group of male friends at that point. A few things I noticed after that gig: the word ‘Titten’ (tits in German – something Xxxxxxx* had kept saying on stage) spelt out in tape right across the path to the main festival area and men sat on chairs either side of it shouting derogatory comments at passing women. I saw girls get aggressively groped as they crowd-surfed, and even saw an older man taking photos up their shorts as they went past him. It was disgusting. One of the most disturbing aspects of the whole thing was that, having explained to the friends I was with exactly why I had found it all so wrong, they still couldn’t see the problem. These people are nice guys, who generally treat women very respectfully, but even they couldn’t see it as more than ‘a bit of fun’. It only hit home when I said to them:
“Imagine if, instead of singling out women and calling them sluts, the lead singer was singling out black people and calling them the ‘N’ word. Would that be ok?! Both behaviours were more so-called ‘acceptable’ and common in the 1980s but, quite rightly, we’ve moved on since then.”
Despite Xxxxxxx*’s misogynistic lyrics that come part and parcel of their tongue-in-cheek, ‘80s spoof persona, I genuinely don’t think that their intention was to do serious harm or to insult anybody. They probably thought it was all harmless nostalgia. However, as men for the most part are not subject to everyday sexism, they often struggle to recognise its existence, never mind the profound impact it can have on women’s lives. Imagining the scenario reversed is ludicrous; unthinkable. If a female lead singer had singled out men, and demanded that they showed off their privates and danced provocatively she would’ve been regarded as mad, at best; at worst, sexually perverted and potentially criminal.

Some of the women on-stage may have got up there in the heat of the moment; on holiday, having fun and feeling carefree. However if any of those women had a job as a schoolteacher, doctor or lawyer, how would it look to their employers if a video of them on-stage, topless and gyrating with Xxxxxxx* emerged to their scrutiny? Remember, this was streamed live on the internet and recorded by thousands on their mobiles – once it’s out there, there’s no getting it back. Xxxxxxx* don’t care if those women’s professional reputations are ruined by a moment of carefree fun. The field full of leering men don’t care – it’s just a ‘laugh’ to them. Even if the women who got up on stage are all currently in careers that don’t set much store by their conduct, there’s always the possibility that a video will pop up in the future when they are in a different career that does. Society shouldn’t care what women do in their free time, but it does, and fiascos like this can ruin lives.