In PSHE lessons, we were taught “stress management techniques” such as “breathing deeply and relaxing”. I am deeply suspicious of anyone who tells me to relax in this way because I have been betrayed by males who told me to do this. These males frequently harassed other women and thought that playing football “like a girl” was the worst thing a man could do!
In PSHE there was all of this talk about how to calm down to fit in with the horrors of real life created by the system. There was no talk of trying to change the system or making it less stressful to benefit everybody!
The terrifying thing is, that most people who told me to breathe deeply and relax basically told me that “Women can’t read maps” and “Men don’t listen”!
I think that the main reason why some men “Don’t listen” is that they live in a society that doesn’t value listening!
In PSHE, we were told that if we had high enough “self esteem” and “tried hard enough at school” we could “be anything we want to be”. There was no practical talk on “How to be a woman scientist, raise a family and look after disabled relatives”. This lesson would’ve helped me so much. We had no such lesson. Nada, zero, zippo, zilch!
We were taught about reproduction, but bizarrely, nothing about the penalties women face in the workforce for having children.
We were just told to “breathe deeply” and accept all of the nonsense society threw our way. Raped? “breathe deeply” Forced to have an abortion? “breathe deeply” Stress out due to an inflexible education system that pathologises individual differences? “Breathe deeply…”
Sorry to be blunt, but I think that the last thing that depressed women need are teachers and social workers telling them to “breathe deeply” when they face sexism and an inflexible system. What would really not make these women depressed is a more flexible and humane system. Talking to a therapist for hours about men who discriminated against you or abused you won’t fix the problem! These men will abuse and discriminate against others regardless of how deeply you breathe or how your therapist “makes you feel”.
This is a plea.
If you’re going to encourage girls and women to do science, accommodate their needs if they want to have families or look after disabled relatives or are disabled themselves.
Don’t just expect by saying: “Hey GIRLS, Science is COOL!”
That this will make all of the sexism, ableism and racism magically vanish.
It won’t.
Only systemic changes will help with these problems.
Then there are implicit biases which breathing deeply can’t fix!
Also, if you’re teaching girls and women about science, do it in a balanced way please. Don’t just include all of the positive stuff, but include ways in which science has been conducted unethically and harmed people.
There were a lot of experiments and drug done on pregnant women that have gone wrong. Girls should know about these before yelling;
“Chemistry is Great!”
Chemistry can poison and kill people. Science isn’t all good. Scientific ideas can be inhumane to different groups of people, women included. Animals may be killed and tortured to develop new drugs. Science has objectified women and Psychiatry used to claim that women had “hysteria” for protesting against abuse. Science is a powerful tool. It has been used in warfare and to hurt women, men and children. Scientific rationalisation has also been used to oppress certain groups of people including women. There used to be an idea that women were mentally inferior to men because their brains were smaller. Now it’s “Women are not good at Science or Logical thinking because their brains are different to Men”.
I am a woman who is depressed now who used to be really keen on science. I wish I had been taught how to see through illusions, think critically and do humane scientific research.
Women and girls need to be taught about fabrication of results and scientific fraud. The futures of their families will depend on them knowing about and putting a stop to corruption in science.
Corruption, systemic inflexibility and sexism cannot be solved by “breathing deeply”.
Also, what good do “body image lessons” in PSHE do, when many men judge women on women’s presentation relative to a “feminine” norm portrayed in porn videos, magazines and TV/Film regardless of how women see themselves?
Making a woman feel good about her appearance will not stop her from being unfairly dismissed from work when pregnant or hostile sexism in the workplace.
These things will only stop when the men (and women) being sexist towards women stop being sexist themselves!

























