Amaranth

Talking to my dad about my sister, who has borderline personality disorder. As a 12-year-old she dated a guy 3 years older for nearly 3 years, who manipulated & abused her emotionally and mentally & repeatedly coerced her into having unprotected sex with him (she refuses the label “rape” and since she’s the only one who knows exactly what happened with him, I respect her choice) over the course of those years, all while she was under the age of consent. He completely screwed with her head for years after in various ways.

Anyway, I won’t go further into that – it would knock off the anonymity. But Dad insisted in that conversation, the day after he finally heard that my sister has been formally diagnosed as having BPD (despite my telling him several times that she had it & was just trying to get it on paper so she could get some help, he ignored me completely til a male doctor said it was true!)…

He decided that she would never have been mentally ill at all if not for that ex-boyfriend. Bear in mind she grew up in a semi-abusive family environment where her dad was an alcoholic who physically assaulted me & my mother in front of her, & brought home several dodgy mates who were horribly lecherous over the two of us as children, and that she was sent home with a letter for threatening a bully with a razor blade she found on the playground at primary school, on top of the fact that our mother had cancer most of our lives and died when we were teenagers… and he thought she developed PTSD and a personality disorder solely because of a teenage boy. I mean, he doesn’t even recognise his own contribution (both us girls have PTSD), but to essentially say that she had no grounds for ever being ill or upset until that one guy came into her life and that he had all that power… It makes me sick.

She’s not been treated well – but her mental health issues, aside from PTSD, are her own. I feel as though by claiming her ex caused them that Dad belittled all the other stuff that she’s been through – and his endless assumptions about the strength of my sister’s personality and how easily it might be influenced, and about her choices in dating, just make me want to get in his face and scream at him that my sister is her own person and that whatever choices she may have made, she did not *choose* to end up with chronic mental health problems and she has never had a personality so easily influenced that solely one teenage boy could screw her up for the rest of her life. She’s stronger than that even when she is at her worst in her illness – and he refuses to even consider that he might be implying not only that she is too *weak* to withstand the immense amount of peer pressure she endured in that relationship, but also that it’s all her fault in the end.

It is not her fault. I wish I could teach him so.