There were few female characters in fictional stories I used to study in English Class. Most of the female characters were minor characters having romances with the main male characters. The female characters would have to be rescued by the male characters or have the male characters do things for them. I’m sorry, but this is why I found English Class boring even though I got okay grades. The adult female characters would have to be attracted to the male characters and talk about their romances constantly.
The only female character in a book I studied in English Class that did not talk about romance was a girl.
*Plot Spoilers Alert*
This girl was a young orphan tear-away who beat up boys for fun. Being an orphan is can be tough, but it’s disturbing for me to see young female orphan characters being portrayed in such a bad light. They are mercilessly dragged along by the plot and forced into situations by overbearing adults. Whenever these female characters show initiative or creativity, they are punished by the system for not behaving “girly” enough. The adults are awful listeners in these stories. These girls are never given a chance to be themselves or express their creativity in a healthy way, but hey, what’s new?
I have read many stories with female characters in my childhood. The rare ones that did have a female protagonist would have the line:
“[Girl Character] found herself in a very strange place with some very strange people…”
The girl character would be forced to go on “fetch quests” by the very strange characters in the “mysterious land”. The girl doesn’t go on the quest because she wants to go, but because other people tell her that she must go. The girl may even be the “missing piece of the puzzle” for the “strange characters”. One story I read, the girl was threatened by greedy male characters to sit in an empty space in a circular statute puzzle so that the men could perform a magical spell to get rich. The girl was told to passively sit in the place of the missing statue so she could become the missing statue for the spell to work. Yes, the spell book said that a “maiden” could be used to replace the statue. Yep, it’s the whole tired-out “virgin maid needed to complete the spell” thing again…Arrrgh!.
A girl in a fantasy story like this never has the agency to do her own thing or make her own decisions without all of the other characters complaining or giving her paternalistic advice. Alice in Wonderland had a rotten time with the angry locals in her stories too.
One such example of paternalistic advice can be found in a Classic Series of fantasy novels. In one of the novels, a group of children have to fight in a battle. For some bizarre reason, Father Christmas gives presents of weapons to the children (yes real weapons, not toys, no CE labels either). Father Christmas tells the girls that they cannot battle on the front line with the boys or use swords because he says that it wouldn’t be “proper” for “ladies” to do this. Sexist Father Christmas gives one of the girls a bow and arrow so she has to take part in the action from a distance while the boys get to be in the thick of it. The other girl is given a potion bottle so she can basically play nurse. Nurses are important: they save peoples’ lives, but there are male nurses too you know! Why wasn’t one of the boys given the healing potion? Are boys told that they aren’t meant to care about sick or injured people and just fight?
The girls are relegated to the side-lines while the boys are celebrated as heroes for engaging in violent warfare. No peace treaty is discussed. Nope, war mongering Father Christmas irresponsibly sets a horrible example for children by sending all of the boys off to war with dangerous weapons and asking the girls to clean up the boys’ mess. Father Christmas, if you are listening, some women compete in fencing tournaments. Fact. Please don’t be surprised if a girl asks for a light-sabre or a plastic sword for Christmas this year.
The only female character in the fictional story who displays any kind of leadership, strategy and agency is a “wicked queen” with “a heart as cold as ice” who turns people to stone. This gives an awful message that women displaying power and agency are dangerous, “too logical to be really female” and “must be stopped”.
Yes, some women abuse power and are corrupt, but does every women in power abuse her power?
Are there good capable women in power?
Where are they in children’s stories?
Some men who write or retell children’s stories seem to be terrified of the idea of a powerful intelligent woman, hence the numerous “wicked witches” and “wicked queens” in fairy tales. Of course, the strong, violent male characters are always portrayed as heroes that “rescue the princess”. Even when male characters kill other “evil” characters, the male heroes murderous actions are celebrated.
The only girl fictional character from my childhood that I can remember taking any initiative at all was Goldilocks. Again, she fits the “wayward young girl” trope. She is hardly the upstanding female role model. Goldilocks trespasses on other animals’ private property, she causes criminal damage to the furniture and steals the animals’ food. She doesn’t enter the house by accident, but deliberately goes inside without the owners’ permission. Yes, she may be hungry and has a curiosity about the world, but she is clearly engaging in criminal activities (according to the law). It always baffled me as to why the bears don’t try and phone the police after goldilocks runs away. The police could have designated the three bears’ house as a crime-scene and collected vital forensic evidence. The police could have arrested Goldilocks for house invasion and asked her to pay damages. People sue the perpetrators for compensation these days! If a girl tried to do anything like this today, she would have to go to court and would end up in a juvenile detention centre.
Unfortunately, Goldilocks is one of the earliest examples of the “dumb blonde” stereotype. The story implies that little girls are so “daft”, “selfish” and “silly” that they don’t think about what they are doing or how this could affect others. As a side note, I think it’s kind of sad that hungry (possibly homeless) girls with a sense of adventure are vilified in stories like this. Where were Goldilocks parents and why weren’t they feeding her enough food? Were they living in poverty on the fringes of society? Goldilocks clearly needed food and shelter and the community did not provide these things for her so she turned to a life of crime. This is shameful.
Most of the rare girl-power style books for children these days either include the “wayward girl” trope or the “girl ninja trope”.
The “girl ninja” usually fights “bad guys” using violent martial arts moves or ties them up with rope. Female American writers usually write these books. The girl characters are given agency and literally bash the plot (and anyone else that gets in the way) into shape with their fists. These stories are enjoyable and action packed, but I wonder about what kind of messages these are sending, that it’s okay to hit or kick someone as long as they are a “bad guy”?
That if you’re a girl and you hit, kick or threaten people with violence, them you have “girl power” and you’re “so cool” and “awesome”?
Children’s stories in my country never have girl characters hitting people (unless they are wayward, victims of circumstance, orphaned or “damaged” girls, see above). I notice that in my country girls in stories are told off for hitting people by adults, think carefully about the consequences of hurting other people and told to go to their room as punishment. Not so with the “American Girl Ninjas”. The female American authors are clearly influenced by martial arts movies and Saturday morning ninja cartoons. As we all know, there is never any blood or consequences in Children’s American Ninja cartoons.
I have never ever seen a story about a sensible non-violent woman who does an intellectually taxing job and having her occupation as the main focus. The main focus would not be a romance with a male character, but the active role of the woman in the community. Would that ever be possible?
Where are Firefighter Frieda, Betty the Builder, and Paula the Plumber?
Where are Ruby the Rugby Player, Laura the Lab Technician and Denise the Dentist?
Where are the female detectives, female lawyers, female police officers and female forensic experts in fictional stories?
Having a story about a female forensic expert or police detective would make for compelling and thrilling GCSE English Coursework option. This would be great for writing exercises predicting what happens next in the story or who students think the culprit is.
A female relative of mine once said that it was a pity that there weren’t more modern, relevant, up to date stories that could be chosen as options for coursework. This relative reads fictional novels by female authors and enjoys mystery stories. She basically said that GCSE English placed too much emphasis on older texts such Shakespeare, not enough attention was paid to modern texts. She said that young people are losing out because they are not being introduced to enough great modern writers by their schools. Modern female writers of different ethnicities tend to be introduced in the poetry section only. Most of the texts I had to study in English Class were written by white men.

























