Went to a film series showcasing local filmmakers’ new work. One film in particular had brilliant, sensitive cinematography, but a pretentious, confusing plot. It starred its 40-something auteur and co-starred a young local actress I happen to know is 19. We got at least 10 minutes of the guy stumbling around (elegantly shot) cityscapes to a minimal jazz soundtrack, timeless in his hornrims and cufflinks, shot from below to look like tall and heroic.
Then we got to the girl. Whom our hero cornered and mumbled at for many minutes. There was a long, artistic shot of her afro billowing, synced to cloud noises, AFTER he’d already approached her and talked and she had barely responded. “You don’t talk much, do you?” said our hero, undeterred. He took her silence as a general “yes,” and squinted and spouted some beat poetry into the dry gray sky for her…benefit?
Then his character *disappeared,* as if by *magic,* for which there was no other precedent in the film. The young woman cast her eyes about furtively, wondering and wishing. Then someone else walked up to her and she started speaking French. The subtitles said something like, a wonderful man had just been there talking to her.
So this is a film, of course, and it can say whatever it wants. The whole time the man/woman scene was happening, I thought it was trying to make the point I was feeling: something about power and presumption, about people using others’ mysterious reserve as a blank screen to project their own romance upon, even though that may really be a misunderstanding. But why did the girl say (in French) how great the guy was? Because the guy wrote it.
There was a talkback. The auteur was there. He talked over and around his wonderful cinematographer, and he had no explanations for why anything that happened in his plot happened, other than “the element of surprise,” and, in a flourish of great PC, “the desire to show that the world is changing. We think this woman is just shy, and then she actually doesn’t speak English.”
Then he brought up the man/woman scene himself, saying, “The other day after a screening, a woman came up to me and told me that scene made her very uncomfortable, and asked if that was my intention. She said the fact that the man was talking to the woman and being near her with no one else around and with her not responding…she found that threatening somehow. And as THIS young woman was talking to ME, I noticed that her body language was really closed off. Like her arms were crossed, and she was clutching her backpack…and I mentioned this to her, that she was really closed. And…you know, I think when someone closes themselves off, they can miss out on the beauty of life. That’s what I told her and I think that’s true.”
The big surprise ending at the end of the film? The young woman gets hit by a bus.
“I think…maybe that was in a way, poetically, the consequence of her not being open?” our hero mused.

























