Karen Heath

I was watching a programme on BBC 2 called Scotland: The Promised Land which was broadcast on 23rd March 2016. The programme highlighted several political figures in post-war Scottish politics (mainly men), there was one woman featured on the show, Jennie Lee, who was described several times as “beautiful”. I was offended by this as none of the men were described by their physical appearance. I wrote to the BBC to complain (see below) and got a pathetic reply back (see further below) but I am going to approach them again as i feel this is just not on. They shoehorn a woman into the show and then see fit to highlight that she was beautiful….grrrrrr.

YOUR COMPLAINT:

Complaint Summary: The description of a female was inappropriate.

Full Complaint: Firstly, I enjoyed the programme,it taught me so much about post-war Scottish politics. The programme detailed several key political figures and described them. The last person to be represented on the show was Jennie Lee, several times when describing Jennie she was described as “beautiful”. To my recollection at no point in the programme did you find it necessary to describe the physical features of any of the male subjects. I feel this was inappropriate – either describe all the subjects’ physical characteristics or none, don’t pick on the woman. What did her being “beautiful” have to do with anything? Thanks for the opportunity to give you my point of view.

Thank you for getting in touch about Scotland: The Promised Land broadcast on 23rd March 2016.

We are always keen to hear feedback about our programmes, both positive and negative, so many thanks for taking the time to contact us. The word “beautiful” was one word, amongst many, used to describe Jennie Lee. We believe it was entirely appropriate in this context and indeed one of uses was by her biographer.

That said, your comments have been fully registered on our daily audience log. This internal document is made available to all our production teams and senior BBC management.

Thank you, once again, for taking the time to contact us.

Kind regards

(Name removed by poster)

BBC Complaints