Anon

I have a few things to say on the topic of “encouraging and inspiring girls into STEM”. When I was younger, I was enthusiastic and excited about Maths and Science. I did not need encouraging! I taught myself concepts and did a lot of reading. I watched educational videos, used computer based resources and observed things in real life.

This all changed as I grew up, particularly at Sixth Form College in Geology Class and I’m some parts of Biology Class. My enthusiasm was sucked out of me by my teachers. Going to class and attending field trips became soul destroying and stressful experiences where teachers would use emotional blackmail and sarcasm on us because they thought that we were all lazy. I slowly lost my passion for these subjects and my will to live.

A male teacher, while he was teaching us Structural Geology, would tell us that women could not visualise 3D objects in their brains. He told us that was why girls struggle with that topic and make mistakes: because our brains supposedly weren’t wired to understand 3D geometry (according to “science”). When boys made mistakes drawing cross-sections, he attributed this to their personal failures to work hard, not because they were male. He’d yell at us or look at us with despair if we made mistakes while we were learning.

Lots of the boys touched me without my consent on field trips and would constantly try to chat me up while I was trying to concentrate on work in the field. The young men would also make rude explicit jokes about women’s anatomy and laugh.

Female teachers would scream and yell at me for various reasons. One time was because I was late (the bus was stuck in traffic after a car crash for two hours), but a female teacher blamed me for this and would not listen to my explanation. She would actually shout at people who were 30 seconds late to class. This made me nervous constantly checking my watch and rushing to class. Some female teachers I had seemed so stressed and would snap and scream if something unexpected went wrong. One female teacher asked me personal questions about my mother’s age then she told me that my practical work was “awful” without calmly explaining where I went wrong or what I could do better next time. She had basically given everyone a worksheet and told them to read said worksheet (with very confusing instructions she did not go through that no one in my class understood) and do lab work during free periods. She said that we could use the lab at any time we liked. She told us we could just walk in and get on with the work.

This was a lie. I tried to enter the lab during one of my free periods only to be screamed at by another female Geography teacher who told me to “get out” because I was “being disruptive”. I was working quietly and looking down a microscope and reading books. I was not talking or disturbing anyone. The only noise I made was walking in quietly. She screamed and shouted at me. I self harmed that night by scratching my wrists and cried. I still have nightmares and flashbacks about this even though I am over 30 years old. I heard voices in my head, not due to a chemical imbalance or “depression”, but due to what teachers said and shouted at me: those voices in my head were their voices! I felt betrayed and lied to. That school was supposed to be an “Investor in People”, but it was traumatising me. It was as if some of the teachers were trying to wrong foot me in science every time. I just couldn’t win.

One time, I used the lab to do some research before a field trip. Fortunately there were no female teachers telling me to get out and screaming like banshees, so I managed to get some work done. There was a microscope, slides and microscopy books. I really had fun drawing sketches of the different igneous rocks. I felt great. I had got a ton of work done and I felt more prepared for the trip. No one else entered the lab and I wondered why I was the only one preparing for the trip. When I was finished, I put the microscopy books back into a neat pile and put the books back exactly where I found them. Sorry, but my mother had brought me up that way to tidy up after myself and leave things organised for other people.

Fortunately, my next class was Geology, so all I had to do was move my books and bags from the lab annex to the classroom next door. My female Geology teacher walked in and inspected the lab annex. She shook her head disapprovingly and then walked back into the classroom. I felt a sinking feeling in the pit of my stomach. I felt like had done something horrible, but I couldn’t figure out what it was yet.

She shouted at the class:
“I can tell that no one has used the lab annex for research because the books are in a neat pile and the slides are just how I left them. I know no one has been in the lab because none of the equipment has been touched. Why are you lot so lazy and you can’t follow basic instructions? And no I don’t want to hear your “excuses” or “explanations”!”

So that was that. I felt too frightened to tell her that I had been working in the lab during free periods and lunch because I was afraid she’d think I was lying. She used to moan at us for leaving the lab in a mess, now she was unknowingly moaning at me for leaving it too tidy as if “no one had used the equipment”. Can’t win either way, just don’t know why I bothered. I cried and scratched my wrists that night, utterly defeated. So sad, angry and yuck in the head.

So please don’t medicate young women for “depression” or “hearing voices”! Instead, make educational environments less stressful and hostile. Calling a young woman “depressed” and suggesting she take pills unfairly individualises a problem that is a community issue. Human beings whether we like it or not are social creatures who are affected by the words other people say and how they treat us. Set high standards, yes, but do this in a respectful way that helps young women learn from their mistakes that doesn’t treat young women like verbal punching bags. More effort should be put into not discouraging and not emotionally abusing young women who are already interested in science.

I am not a verbal punching bag for teacher’s frustrations or someone you stick a pernicious psychiatric label on. I am a human being who tries to listen and be polite. I felt lied to by the Sixth Form College prospectus that said the school environment valued “equality”, “diversity” and “inspired students by supporting them to fulfil their potential”. It was all just fancy buzz words and lip-service. Every week there would be some “scientific” lecture on at the school about how the “male brain” was supposedly better at science and maths. Also how empathetic female brains could not be good at Maths because they supposedly didn’t have “systemising” brains like men did. Um explain my female Maths teachers then? Oh and that woman who won the Field’s medal, what about her? Crickets…Silence…

I got an As in Geology and Biology by working alone in spite of my teachers not because of them.

Sorry, but this is the truth.

I wish I had something inspiring and uplifting to say, but I really don’t.