I have been thinking long and hard (I have no life truly) about the censorship of the Beano (containing Minnie the Minx), superhero books and “passive princess” books in the name of a televised “gender equality” social experiment at a Primary School. Censoring children’s books just because as experimenter does not like them seems to me well just sort of childish. Also, censoring reading material (including the Beano) because it supposedly is “aimed at boys” and therefore supposedly (according to the experimenter) “puts girls off of doing engineering” is downright bizarre given that Minnie the Minx invents contraptions to do mischief and thus is a female engineer of sorts!
I am not a Primary School teacher, but if I was one, I would have approached the issue of gender in children’s stories in a different way. How about not censoring of any of the so called “gender offensive” storybooks in a the class library, but instead asking the children to read some stories critically and asking them to choose which were their favourites and least favourites?
The children could be asked to discuss and write their opinions about the stories and compare their opinions to other children who had read the same stories that they had. They could debate their points of view and realise that different people have different preferences for gender roles, lifestyles and therefore different opinions to their own. It’s called having a productive discussion and would actually help the children become more mature and aware of different genres of literature.
I would probably make a rubbish Primary School teacher, but my lesson plan (probably in a Literacy Class) would have gone something like this:
-Compare and contrast three stories
-Which was your favourite story?
Explain why
-Which was your least favourite story?
Explain why
-Explain how some of the stories you have written have similar plots to films you have seen or video games you have played. What are the differences? List all the media you reference in your report.
-Read worksheets on chilvary, medieval history, who wrote (including female authors!) medieval stories about so called “damsels in distress” and knights etc
-Read worksheets on Greek/Norse/Other cultures heroes and mythology.
-Are heroes always male? Why or why not, give reasons
-Is female beauty and gentleness always a bad thing?
-What is a hero?
Etc
Also I would also dedicate several science lessons to the contraptions made by Minnie the Minx. Then I would probably be thrown out of the school (if I was a teacher) for using a fictional anti authoritarian controversial female inventor to teach science to impressionable youngsters.
Strangely, the experimenter in the TV documentary says that he wants to discourage competition in episode 1 of the show because he seems to associate competition with “destructive male behaviour” for some reason. Then for some inexplicable head-scratching reason, he gets all the children to participate in a football match where goals are scored in episode 2. Huh?! Isn’t football technically a “competitive sport” according to him?! If the experimenter abhors competition (he associates it with “Male anger” and supposed “lack of empathy” which is very sexist given that many females are highly competitive too!) then why is he getting the kids to compete against each other? The man seems unable to defend his points with a consistent argument.
It is interesting to note that the male experimenter in the programme associates toy guns only with boys, so he tells the parents of the children to ban toy guns from their houses.
This is very strange given that one of the mothers says that there are pink girls’ toy guns in her house “Nerf Rebelle” so what is she supposed to do with those?! Good point, what is she supposed to do with toy guns marketed at girls? Does the experimenter believe that girls not meant to shoot pheasants when they are older or join the army or are guns just wrong for everyone because they are violent?
The experimenter asks a boy who is resident in this house about his toy guns. The boy says that: “Nerf guns for boys are better than Nerf Rebelle guns for girls.”
At this point the experimenter seems strangely confused and says: “I don’t know what you are talking about.” Then he just ignores the boy’s thoughtful comments and just says that you guns are “violent and aimed at boys”.
I can’t believe that this man (who is a doctor of something) and is supposedly studying children’s gender issues does not know what a Nerf Rebelle toy gun is! I know what they are and I hardly get out at all. I just hope that this man was feigning ignorance on the topic or this is all just a ruse and that the last episode will have Jeremy Beadle finally appear to end our misery.
I mean this has to be some kind of funny practical candid camera type of joke right? Right?!
While I believe in equal opportunities for all genders, the male experimenter’s bizarre and head-scratchingly hypocritical attempts at so called “gender equality” mean that I and many others just can’t take him seriously. This a great shame given the gendered discrimination that many people face in the real world.

























