I was home for Christmas this year and was cooking in the kitchen with my parents and some relatives on Christmas Eve when my brother in law came in. My skin crawled in repulsion as he has a history of making inappropriate comments towards me and other young girls in our family (right after my sister had my nephew I was babysitting and he documented my friends’ bodies with salivating detail and rated them out of ten, right in front of my sister who had recently given birth). Well he came in and said “I won’t hug you as I have a cold” and I breathed a sigh of relief even though his reference to physical contact is still, I believe, a way of him signalling that he ultimately holds power over whether he will touch me or not. He then asked how things were and I joked that I was blessed, things were going well with my job and I had a new flat. He responded “you are blessed: good looking, hot body and intelligent too”. I felt physically sick. I felt that he was sexualising me and even my brother said “Jesus, woah there”. Two days later I mentioned to my parents in passing that he had been inappropriate when they were talking about an irritation they had with him. They then minimised, invalidated and gaslighted me. They said repeatedly that it wouldn’t help anyone to say anything about his comment. I said repeatedly that I had no intention of saying anything but they persisted in making the conversation about this. They missed an opportunity to emphatically denounce his behaviour and offer clear, compassionate statements of support in a soft sympathetic tone. Instead, they made the conversation about me, my behaviour and my choices. My father told me that because my brother in law is a labourer and I have a medical degree that I have more power than him and that it shouldn’t bother me and that if it did I should have stood up for myself. Because I am more articulate, he reasoned, I have more power. Well, arguments about this claim aside my articulateness has no power in this conversation, I quickly discovered. I laid out my analysis as clearly as I could using all the words and education at my disposal and still they claimed that they were being nothing but supportive and they could not understand. My father said that the comment was intended as a compliment. He then advised me to learn how to toughen up and deal with “mean” comments. I told them that there was a difference between “meanness” and sexual degradation and that they were minimising and invalidating my experience and they said that they were doing neither and how dare I interpret it that way and make such awful assumptions about them. I got so frustrated I shouted and they told me that my anger was out of control and that I was making a big deal out of it and was ruining Christmas. And honestly, it’s not the comment itself but the twisted logic of the systemic response to the comment that has stirred up such rage, and it is just that: rage. It is a heat in my belly that wants to scream and scream. I resent having to take on the responsibility of explaining to them why it should be my right to define either the comment was inappropriate, not theirs. But we were speaking different languages and I felt powerless and frustrated. And that is why I am not blessed. Because neither my “beauty” nor my intelligence have ever saved me nor have they offered any solutions to this endless onslaught. I hope that others can relate. We have a long way to go, please let’s keep fighting together. Sending solidarity to others this Christmas.

























