Anon

A leaflet about “supporting teenagers” in my country published by so called “experienced” psychotherapists contains a lot of pernicious gender stereotypes. The reason why I despair about living in my country is that girls get stereotyped as behaving one way and boys get stereotyped as behaving the opposite way, even when in reality there is a lot of overlap of behaviours between the sexes!

In the leaflet, girls are automatically assumed to be “vulnerable” and in need of “empowering”.

This is kind of offensive and degrading to many young women who are capable and self sufficient. Some women do not view themselves as “helpless victims”, but instead as highly capable survivors!

Calling girls “vulnerable” or fragile doesn’t help them deal with stuff in an adaptive or a resilient way. While it is true that some young women struggle with issues around eating (please don’t use the pathologising words “eating disorder” because it is society’s expectations around food that are disordered, not the young women themselves). Once again, the fact that many young men also engage in anorexic or bulimic behaviours is conveniently ignored by the leaflet. This is sexist because young men are under pressure by the media too. Young men are pressurised to be lean and muscular by society and this cannot be ignored!

In the leaflet, girls are called “over conscientious and perfectionistic daughters”. Seriously? What is wrong with doing things thoroughly and properly? Do people want girls to slap-dash and half finish tasks? Would you want an airline pilot who didn’t do safety checks before take-off, a doctor who prescribed you the wrong drug or a nuclear power plant worker who was not conscientious? I mean come on, some jobs require stringent “perfectionism” or you get fired or sued because a slap-dash attitude would cost lives!

In Chemistry Class, I had to titrate chemicals according to strict concentration values in solution. If I measured the mass of chemicals wrong or used the wrong volume of distilled water, the experiment would not work and the results would have been useless. I had to also be thorough when writing up lab reports because marks would be deducted from my final grade if I was not. It is fantastic to aim for perfection because it meant that I obtained maximum marks possible for the planning part of the Chemistry Coursework. Nothing beats getting 100% marks on a task, it is truly an awesome feeling! So no, I don’t think that girls should be denied the opportunity to excel by people who call them “too perfectionistic”. Heck, what this world so desperately needs is more high achieving young women!

Even TV competitions such as “dress making” or “bake off” require precise measurements and the right amount of ingredients for the clothes to actually fit or cakes not to explode in the oven respectively. Lots of women take part in these shows and do well.

Please, instead of pathologising girls and young women for their hard work and diligence, praise them for it! Give credit where credit is due for crying out loud!

I do sense that in my country there is a culture of anti intellectualism and dare I say it, people are jealous of young women’s achievements, so some teachers, parents and “professionals” tell girls that they are “too perfectionistic” or “over contentious” because I don’t know they are envious of the female youth today? My grandmother liked to do things thoroughly and properly as part of her job. She would be rolling in her grave now if she heard that young women are actively being discouraged from being conscientious and doing a thorough job by “well meaning adults”.

In some Asian countries, such effort and thoroughness by women would be praised and actively encouraged. I am amazed at how young women and men are encouraged to strive to do the best the can and aim for high standards in some Asian countries. The toys, the games, the TV shows, everything encourage people to try hard and improve themselves. Young women in some Asian countries are told that perfection is a virtue that they should strive for. While this has the unfortunate effect of some Asian women wanting plastic surgery, it does mean that Asian women are lauded for the “perfection” of the hard work that they do in intellectual pursuits.

In the leaflet about “supporting teenagers”, boys are unfairly stereotyped as all being “laid back ‘do it all at the last minute’ lads”. I have seen some boys spend hours researching in the library weeks in advance of a deadline. Lots of these young men were boys of Asian origin, but there were definitely some white Caucasian boys and all other ethnicities of boys studying hard too! This is why it is sexist and unfair to label the entire male gender as “laid back” and lazy in this way.

Sometimes being “laid back” isn’t lazy at all! Sometimes one needs time to mull over and consider all options carefully before reaching a decision. Some people like to look at the “big picture” of the situation before they focus on the details.

I have also met sone “laid back last minute” girls who were high achievers! Fun fact: a close female friend of mine had a habit of leaving her homework until the night before it was due. Despite her procrastination, she always ended up getting A grades. Explain that then “psychology experts”! Oh wait…you can’t…

I have also met some very lazy, unconscientious girls who often didn’t submit their homework at all! Some girls really are bored and disengaged with school as the “Lauren Cooper” “Am I bovvered?” sketches sadly parody.

This leaflet is part of the problem, not part of the solution. If you stereotype males as lazy and disengaged with studying, it may become a self fulfilling prophesy because some adults had low expectations of them!

Wouldn’t it be better instead to encourage everyone to be thorough, aim for high standards and do their best regardless of whether they are female, male or other?

Just sayin’…